Top Salmon Sportfishing Company In NY

Pulaski NY Charter Reviews 

What Guests Say About Jay's Sportfishing

Quote icon

Stripers Galore

What an incredible trip—nonstop striper action from start to finish! Jason was super friendly, easy to talk to, and full of great info throughout the day. Already planning our next trip with him!


Andy G.

Quote icon

Captain Jay Wows

Captain Jay was incredibly helpful from start to finish. He stayed in touch before the trip and tailored the experience to exactly what we were hoping for. His expertise on the water really showed, and the boat was stocked with top-notch, well-maintained gear. Easy 5/5—we’ll definitely be booking again!


Aria F.

Quote icon

Bluefin Bonanza

Captain Jay had us on bluefin more than once, and we ended up landing a 400-pound giant! The whole crew had an awesome time out there. Definitely recommend fishing with Dead On!


Alexis S.

Quote icon

Tuna Triumph at Sea

We had an unforgettable day on the water with Captain Jay and first mate Matt. While nothing’s ever guaranteed in fishing, having a crew that truly knows their stuff makes all the difference—and these guys absolutely do. We spent the full day aboard Jay’s boat and were lucky enough to hook and land a stunning bluefin tuna. What an experience! It’s a memory that’ll stick with me for a long time. I’d head out with Captain Jay again in a heartbeat. Thanks again, guys!


Jared M.

Curious what it's like to fish with Jay's Sportfishing in Pulaski NY? Our customer testimonials say it all. From first-timers to seasoned anglers, guests consistently rave about the fun, friendly atmosphere and the captain’s deep knowledge of the Salmon River and Lake Ontario. Whether it’s a monster king salmon or a fast-paced steelhead run, our reviews highlight successful trips, great gear, and a guide who truly goes the extra mile. Many anglers even book year after year, pointing to Jay’s professionalism, patience with kids, and ability to find fish in all conditions.


These Pulaski NY fishing charter reviews reflect real experiences—families bonding over big catches, friends checking a trophy off their bucket list, and solo anglers landing their personal best. If you're looking for a reliable charter captain, expert local knowledge, and a trip that guests call “the highlight of our vacation,” Jay’s Sportfishing is the name to trust. Read the stories, see the smiles, and book your own unforgettable fishing adventure today.